News and insights · BDi Advance Fire & Security

Biometric Access Control: The Pros and Cons for Your Business

Biometric Access Control_ Pros and Cons

A lost fob can be cancelled, but what if staff could enter authorised areas without carrying one? A biometric access control system uses characteristics such as fingerprints or facial features to check someone’s identity before allowing entry.

This can offer practical advantages, particularly where businesses want to reduce credential sharing. However, biometrics also introduce questions about privacy, reliability and everyday use.

Before choosing biometric entry systems, weigh the security benefits against the additional responsibilities. The right approach depends on your premises, workforce and reasons for controlling access.

How Does a Biometric Access Control System Work?

Users usually complete an enrolment process so the system can create a biometric reference, often called a template. When they request entry, a fresh sample is compared with that reference.

A biometric access control reader works with the wider system to determine whether the person has permission to enter that door at that time.

Fingerprint access control is one option. Facial recognition provides another, while some arrangements combine biometrics with a card or PIN. Storage methods, matching processes and security features vary between products.

Pro: Reduce Reliance on Shareable Credentials

Cards can be lent to colleagues and PINs can be passed on. Biometrics make casual credential sharing more difficult because access depends on checking a characteristic associated with the enrolled person.

This can be useful for restricted areas where knowing who used a credential matters.

However, biometric identification does not prevent someone from following an authorised user through a door. Appropriate door hardware, staff awareness and procedures remain necessary.

Pro: Fewer Lost Cards and Fobs

Where biometrics replace physical credentials, staff have fewer items to remember. Businesses may also spend less time issuing replacements and cancelling missing tokens.

For regular users, this can make entry convenient. However, enrolment still requires administration, and businesses need arrangements for visitors, contractors and people using an alternative method.

Convenience should be assessed against the complete process, including how quickly users can enter during busy periods.

Pro: Work Alongside Existing Access Permissions

A compatible biometric access system can use the same door permissions and time schedules as other credentials.

For example, an employee might have access to the main entrance during working hours while remaining restricted from a stockroom.

Some biometric readers can integrate with established platforms. Paxton documents compatible fingerprint reader integrations for Net2, although suitability must be checked against the specific equipment and configuration. An upgrade does not automatically require replacing the whole system.

Con: Additional Data Protection Responsibilities

Biometric data used to uniquely identify someone is special category personal data. Organisations need both a lawful basis and an appropriate special category condition before processing it. Explicit consent may be appropriate, but it must provide genuine choice, including a suitable alternative without disadvantage.

The ICO says employers must complete a data protection impact assessment before using biometrics to uniquely identify workers. Its guidance also highlights explaining the processing to staff, protecting templates and limiting retention. These considerations belong in the planning stage.

Con: Performance Depends on the Setting

A reader that works well in an office may be less suitable for a demanding workplace.

With fingerprint access control, assess whether gloves, dirt, moisture or changes to users’ fingertips could affect operation. For face recognition access control, consider lighting, positioning and anything obscuring the face.

Ask suppliers to demonstrate performance under representative conditions. Check false acceptance and rejection performance, accessibility and protection against spoofing. Avoid assuming that every user or entrance will achieve identical results.

Con: Costs Extend Beyond the Reader

Compare the full installation and running costs, including integration, licences, enrolment and maintenance.

A biometric access control reader may require compatible controllers or software changes. Cleaning, updates and fault support also need consideration.

Biometric information requires particularly careful protection because a compromised fingerprint cannot simply be replaced like a fob. Ask where templates are stored, who can access them and how they are secured and deleted.

Is Biometric Access Control Right for Your Business?

Start with the problem you need to solve. If a well-managed card or fob system meets your needs, biometrics may add complexity without sufficient benefit.

Where stronger identity checks are justified, assess the proposed technology alongside its practical and privacy implications. Plan alternative entry, support for failed recognition and safe emergency arrangements.

BDi Advance can review your premises and discuss suitable access control options. Speak to our team about an approach that fits your building, users and security requirements.

Next step

Free site visit and quotation

If you are planning a CCTV, access control, intruder alarm or fire system project, we will visit your site, look at what needs protecting and then design a system to suit the building and the budget. There is no charge for the visit.

Talk to us about your project

Book a free site surveyCall 01223 566 599No charge for the visit

Related articles